O-Ring Materials: NBR, EPDM, FKM, Silicone and Neoprene Compared

Five compounds cover almost everything we quote: NBR, EPDM, FKM, silicone and neoprene. They are not five grades of one material. They fail in different ways, at different temperatures, against different media, and choosing between them is the decision that decides whether a seal lasts five years or five weeks.

This page puts the five side by side, then sends you to the one that fits. Each compound has its own page with the temperature range, the media it cannot take, and the grades we quote, because a comparison table cannot carry a caveat and a seal often depends on a caveat.

The Five Compounds, Side By Side

Property NBR EPDM FKM Silicone Neoprene
ISO 1629 code NBR EPDM FKM VMQ CR
Hardness (Shore A) 40 to 90 40 to 90 50 to 90 30 to 80 40 to 90
Temperature range −40 to 100 °C −50 to 150 °C −20 to 200 °C −60 to 200 °C −40 to 120 °C
Mineral oil and grease Excellent Poor Excellent Fair Good
Fuel and aromatic solvent Good Poor Excellent Poor Fair
Water and steam Fair Excellent Poor Fair Good
Ozone and weather Poor Excellent Good Excellent Excellent
Dilute acid and base Fair Good Good Fair Good
Compression set at temperature Good Good Excellent Fair Fair
Tear strength Good Good Good Poor Excellent
Relative cost Low Low to moderate High Moderate to high Low to moderate
Chosen for Oil and general industry Water, steam and weather Heat, fuel and chemistry Cold and clean service Outdoor plus oil

Ratings compare the five classes at 70 Shore A and are qualitative: excellent, good, fair, poor. They describe the compound class, not a specific grade, and a compound chosen for one property is usually weaker in another. Cost is relative within this table, not a price.

How To Choose, In Four Steps

  1. Start with the medium. Oil and fuel point to NBR or FKM. Water, steam and weather point to EPDM. Refrigerant points to neoprene. Most wrong material choices are made before the temperature is even considered.
  2. Then the temperature. It eliminates more compounds than any other single figure, because the medium you need may not survive the heat you have. Above 150 °C only FKM and silicone are left. Below −40 °C the list narrows to silicone and the low temperature grades of EPDM and NBR, and the grade has to be named on the drawing.
  3. Then the duty. A dynamic joint needs tear strength, which rules silicone out under pressure. A static joint on a hot flange needs compression set resistance, which points to FKM or a peroxide cured EPDM.
  4. Then the approval. Food, drinking water and medical service each need a certificate, and a compound that is right on paper but unapproved will not pass an audit.

If two compounds survive those four steps, take the cheaper one. There is no prize for specifying FKM where NBR would have lasted ten years, and a buyer who over specifies pays twice: once on the ring, and again when the replacement is not in stock.

The Page For Each Compound

What This Matrix Does Not Cover

Five compounds cover most of what we quote, not all of it. HNBR sits between NBR and FKM for hot oil and is quoted on request. FFKM, a perfluoroelastomer, handles temperatures and solvents that FKM cannot and costs several times as much. Polyurethane is used for rod seals and wipers rather than O-rings. PTFE and filled PTFE are for chemical duty and low friction. Fluorosilicone is the answer when silicone’s temperature range is needed in fuel.

The matrix also does not cover approvals. FDA, WRAS, NSF 61, USP Class VI and the ASTM D2000 line callout system each work in their own language, and a compound that meets one does not automatically meet another. Send the approval with the drawing and we quote the grade that carries it.

Questions We Get Asked

Which compound is the general purpose one?
NBR, for anything carrying oil or grease. EPDM takes over as soon as the medium is water or the joint is outdoors. Between them those two cover the majority of industrial joints, and the other three are for the cases where temperature or chemistry rules one of them out.

Can I use the same compound for every size?
Yes, and it is usually the right way to buy. The compound is chosen for the duty and the size for the groove, so a plant standardising on 70 Shore A NBR across its spares list is making a sound decision as long as no joint sees water, steam or solvent.

Does hardness change the temperature range?
It changes both ends of it, and a 90 Shore A compound is usually rated a little lower at the top and a little higher at the bottom than a 70 of the same polymer. The figures on this page are for 70 Shore A, which is the hardness most drawings call for.

What if the medium is a mixture?
Send the mixture rather than the main ingredient. A 5 percent aromatic content in a solvent changes the answer, and so does a corrosion inhibitor in a water circuit. Where the duty is continuous and the mixture is unfamiliar, we would rather test a sample than guess from a table.

Request a Quote

滚动至顶部